Must Haves

31 products

    Our top must-have toys for babies and toddlers. Here are three great reasons to click/tap 'add to cart' 1. Because they are loved by gift-givers and kiddos alike. 2. They're often found in hot-toy gift guides. 3. The reviews speak for themselves, with 4.7+ star reviews on nearly every toy! Find teether and grasping toys for babies, activity toys and dolls for toddlers, and plushies for all.

    31 products
    Baby Whoozit - Baby Toys - Manhattan Toy
    Baby Whoozit
    Musical Lili Llama - Wood Toys - Manhattan Toy
    Musical Lili Llama - Wood Toys - Manhattan Toy
    Musical Lili Llama
    Winkel Colorpop - Manhattan Toy
    Winkel Colorpop - Manhattan Toy
    Winkel Colorpop
    Sold Out
    Deer One - Soft Books - Manhattan Toy
    Deer One - Baby Books - Manhattan Toy
    Deer One Soft Book
    Skwish Color Burst - Baby Toys - Manhattan Toy
    Skwish Color Burst - Baby Toys - Manhattan Toy
    Skwish Color Burst
    Wimmer Seek & Explore Mat soft baby play mat
    Wimmer Seek & Explore Mat
    Crab Floating Fill n Spill - Bath Toys - Manhattan Toy
    Crab Floating Fill n Spill - Bath Toys - Manhattan Toy
    Crab Floating Fill n Spill
    Winkel - Baby Toys - Manhattan Toy
    Winkel - Baby Toys - Manhattan Toy
    Winkel
    Sold Out
    Wimmer Sensory Fun-Damentals Gift Set group visual of four included baby toys
    Wimmer Sensory Fun-Damentals Gift Set baby ball toy
    Wimmer Sensory Fun-Damentals Gift Set
    Sold Out
    soft baby doll with peach skin and blonde hair tuft in a pink dress seated with a pink magnetic pacifier off to the side
    soft baby doll with peach skin and a blonde hair tuft in a dress standing with magnetic pacifier attached to the face
    Love, Stella Peach Doll with Blonde Tuft
    Skwish Natural - Baby Toys - Manhattan Toy
    Skwish Natural - Baby Toys - Manhattan Toy
    Skwish Natural
    Playground Adventure - Wood Toys - Manhattan Toy
    Playground Adventure - Wood Toys - Manhattan Toy
    Playground Adventure
    Lanky Cats Ziggie Stuffed Animal - Stuffed Animal - Manhattan Toy
    Lanky Cats Ziggie Stuffed Animal - Stuffed Animal - Manhattan Toy
    Lanky Cats Ziggie Stuffed Animal
    Fairytale Peek-a-boo Soft Book - Baby Books - Manhattan Toy
    Fairytale Peek-a-boo Soft Book - Baby Books - Manhattan Toy
    Fairytale Peek-a-boo Soft Book
    seated beige soft baby doll with brown pigtails in blue dress seated with pink magnetic pacifier off to the side
    standing beige soft baby doll with brown pigtails in blue dress seated with pink magnetic pacifier attached to the face
    Love, Stella Beige Doll with Brown Pigtails
    Put & Peek Birdhouse - Baby Toys - Manhattan Toy
    Put & Peek Birdhouse - Baby Toys - Manhattan Toy
    Put & Peek Birdhouse
    Celestial Star Explorer - Toddler Toys - Manhattan Toy
    Celestial Star Explorer - Toddler Toys - Manhattan Toy
    Celestial Star Explorer
    Flutter By Birdie Book - Baby Books - Manhattan Toy
    Flutter By Birdie Book - Baby Books - Manhattan Toy
    Flutter By Birdie Book
    soft baby snuggle doll with brown skin that includes a magnetic pacifier
    soft baby snuggle doll with brown skin that includes a magnetic pacifier
    Love, Stella My First Doll Brown
    Wimmer Discovery Mirror tummy time toy
    Wimmer Discovery Mirror
    Folklore Fun-gi - Sorting & Stacking Toys - Manhattan Toy
    Folklore Fun-gi - Sorting & Stacking Toys - Manhattan Toy
    Folklore Fun-gi
    Wild Ones Bean Bag Toss Game
    Sold Out
    pretend feeding set with a food bowl with gel-filled top a plastic spoon a fabric bib and magnetic bottle
    toddler age girl seated, pretending to feed soft baby doll with pretend spoon and food bowl
    Love, Stella Feeding Set
    Wimmer Grasp & See Mirror infant grasping toy
    Baby lying on a soft rug, grasping a high-contrast circular mirror toy with colorful tabs, supported by an adult's hands.
    Wimmer Grasp & See Mirror
    Lanky Cats Pink Mochi Stuffed Animal - Stuffed Animals - Manhattan Toy
    Lanky Cats Pink Mochi Stuffed Animal - Stuffed Animals - Manhattan Toy
    Lanky Cats Pink Mochi Stuffed Animal
    soft baby snuggle doll with beige skin that includes a magnetic pacifier
    soft baby snuggle doll with beige skin that includes a magnetic pacifier
    Love, Stella My First Doll Light Beige
    Sold Out
    Whistleball Colorpop - Manhattan Toy
    happy baby playing with a colorful toy ball
    Whistleball Colorpop
    peach skinned soft baby doll with pink beanie and magnetic pacifier on the face laid in a fabric doll sized bassinet
    blue and peach colored fabric doll sized bassinet with handles and a love stella logo
    Love, Stella My First Doll Peach & Bassinet
    Side view of a Manhattan Toy wooden zebra activity center featuring bead runs, a springy bird, spinning flower, and clacking ears.
    Manhattan Toy wooden zebra activity toy with labeled features including bead runs, spinning flower, springy bird, and rotating animal panels.
    Safari Zebra Activity Toy
    soft baby snuggle doll with beige skin that includes a magnetic pacifier
    soft baby snuggle doll with beige skin and brown hair that includes a magnetic pacifier
    Love, Stella My First Doll Beige
    Sold Out
    Click Clack Colorpop - Manhattan Toy
    Click Clack Colorpop