3-5 Years

Find the perfect holiday or birthday gifts for 3-5 year olds. Choose from wood activity toys to soft washable dolls to plush, musical toys and more. There's something for every young toddler in your life. 
157 products
Quick view
Lanky Cats Ziggie - Manhattan Toy
Lanky Cats Ziggie - Manhattan Toy
Lanky Cats Ziggie Stuffed Animal
$19.00
Quick view
Cozy Bunch Camel
$25.00
Quick view
Kodiak Bear 18" White Stuffed Animal
$60.00
Quick view
Kodiak Bear - Manhattan Toy
Kodiak Bear - Manhattan Toy
Kodiak Bear 40" Brown Stuffed Animal
$470.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Lyle, Lyle Crocodile Plush Large
$25.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Little Nook Bluebell Bear
$19.00
Quick view
Octopus Navy Blue
$18.00
Quick view
Alpine Express Wooden Toy Train Set
$65.00
Quick view
Baby Stella Beige Doll with Brown Hair - Manhattan Toy
Baby Stella Beige Doll with Brown Hair - Manhattan Toy
Baby Stella Beige Doll with Brown Pigtails
$41.00
Quick view
Baby Stella Blissful Blooms High Chair - Manhattan Toy
Baby Stella Blissful Blooms High Chair - Manhattan Toy
Baby Stella Blissful Blooms High Chair Doll Accessory
$40.00
Quick view
Baby Stella Brown Doll - Manhattan Toy
Baby Stella Brown Doll - Manhattan Toy
Baby Stella Brown Doll with Black Hair
$41.00
Quick view
Baby Stella Learn To Dress Doll - Manhattan Toy
Baby Stella Dress Up Doll
$37.00
Quick view
Baby Stella Peach Doll with Black Pigtails - Manhattan Toy
Baby Stella Peach Doll with Black Pigtails - Manhattan Toy
Baby Stella Peach Doll with Black Hair
$41.00
Quick view
Early Bird Espresso
$34.00
Quick view
Baby Stella Peach Doll with Yellow Pigtails - Manhattan Toy
Baby Stella Peach Doll with Yellow Pigtails - Manhattan Toy
Baby Stella Peach Doll with Blonde Hair
$41.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Baby Stella Peach Doll with Light Brown Hair
$41.00
Quick view
Baby Stella Peach Fella Doll with Yellow Hair - Manhattan Toy
Baby Stella Peach Fella Doll with Yellow Hair - Manhattan Toy
Baby Stella Peach Fella Doll with Blonde Hair
$41.00
Quick view
Baby Stella Pretty in Pink
$22.00
Quick view
Baby-Stella-Trendy-Trekker Manhattan Toy
Baby Stella Trendy Trekker
$22.00
Quick view
Baby Stella Welcome Baby Accessory Set
$28.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Beats To Go - Manhattan Toy
Beats To Go - Manhattan Toy
This product does not ship to Canada.
Beats To Go
$44.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Bed-&-Biscuit-Frenchie Manhattan Toy
Bed-&-Biscuit-Frenchie Manhattan Toy
Bed & Biscuit Frenchie
$34.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Bed-&-Biscuit-Labradoodle Manhattan Toy
Bed-&-Biscuit-Labradoodle Manhattan Toy
Bed & Biscuit Labradoodle
$34.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Bed-&-Biscuit-Lhasapoo Manhattan Toy
Bed-&-Biscuit-Lhasapoo Manhattan Toy
Bed & Biscuit Lhasapoo
$34.00
Quick view
Bocce Ball
$47.50
Quick view
Bunny Hop Mixer
$44.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Celestial-Star-Explorer Manhattan Toy
Celestial-Star-Explorer Manhattan Toy
Celestial Star Explorer
$210.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Chickens Cooper - Manhattan Toy
Chickens Cooper - Manhattan Toy
Chickens Cooper
$20.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Chickens Henley - Manhattan Toy
Chickens Henley - Manhattan Toy
Chickens Henley
$20.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Chickens Megg - Manhattan Toy
Chickens Megg - Manhattan Toy
Chickens Megg
$20.00
Quick view
Cozy Bunch Deer
$25.00
Quick view
Cozy-Bunch-Giraffe Manhattan Toy
Cozy-Bunch-Giraffe Manhattan Toy
Cozy Bunch Giraffe
$25.00
Quick view
Cozy-Bunch-Horse Manhattan Toy
Cozy-Bunch-Horse Manhattan Toy
Cozy Bunch Horse
$25.00
Quick view
Cozy Bunch Llama
$25.00
Quick view
Cozy-Bunch-Zebra Manhattan Toy
Cozy-Bunch-Zebra Manhattan Toy
Cozy Bunch Zebra
$25.00
Quick view
Deep Sea Adventure - Manhattan Toy
Deep Sea Adventure - Manhattan Toy
Deep Sea Adventure
$130.00
Quick view
Deep-Sea-Dive-Bath-Book Manhattan Toy
Deep-Sea-Dive-Bath-Book Manhattan Toy
Deep Sea Dive Bath Book
$25.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Flicker Manhattan Toy
Flicker Manhattan Toy
Flashlight Flicker
$21.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Flyer Manhattan Toy
Flashlight Flyer
$21.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Flora-&-Fauna-Tea-Set Manhattan Toy
Flora-&-Fauna-Tea-Set Manhattan Toy
Flora & Fauna Tea Set
$63.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Folklore Fun-gi
$31.50
Sold Out
Quick view
Folklore-Quartet Manhattan Toy
Folklore-Quartet Manhattan Toy
Folklore Quartet
$34.00
Quick view
Forest Tales Baking Set
$60.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Hans Bear - Manhattan Toy
Hans Bear - Manhattan Toy
Hans Bear Stuffed Animal Teddy Bear
$28.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Pink-Mochi Manhattan Toy
Pink-Mochi Manhattan Toy
Lanky Cats Pink Mochi Stuffed Animal
$19.00
Quick view
LEGO Star Wars Ewok Plush Minifigure
$31.50
Quick view
LEGO Star Wars R2-D2 Plush Minifigure
$31.50
Sold Out
Quick view
Little Nook Berry Bunny
$19.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Little Nook Lily Cat
$19.00
Quick view
Little-Rocket-Finds-Home Manhattan Toy
Little-Rocket-Finds-Home Manhattan Toy
Little Rocket Finds Home
$25.50
Quick view
Making Faces Magnetic Set - Manhattan Toy
Making Faces Magnetic Set - Manhattan Toy
Making Faces Magnetic Set
$31.50
Quick view
Making Faces Memory Game - Manhattan Toy
Making Faces Memory Game
$15.50
Quick view
MiO Carriage + Horse + 1 Person - Manhattan Toy
MiO Carriage + Horse + 1 Person - Manhattan Toy
MiO Carriage + Horse + 1 Person
$18.00
Quick view
MiO Me Time - Manhattan Toy
MiO Me Time - Manhattan Toy
MiO Me Time
$10.00
Quick view
MiO School Bus + 2 People - Manhattan Toy
MiO School Bus + 2 People - Manhattan Toy
MiO School Bus + 2 People
$17.00
Quick view
Musical Chicken - Manhattan Toy
Musical Chicken
$58.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Musical-Diego-Dino Manhattan Toy
Musical-Diego-Dino Manhattan Toy
Musical Diego Dino
$58.00
Quick view
Natural Historian Camera - Manhattan Toy
Natural Historian Camera - Manhattan Toy
Natural Historian Camera
$19.00
Quick view
Night-Night-Sleigh-Bed Manhattan Toy
Night-Night-Sleigh-Bed Manhattan Toy
Night Night Sleigh Bed
$50.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Nursing Nana Dog - Manhattan Toy
Nursing Nana Dog - Manhattan Toy
Nursing Nana Dog
$33.00
Quick view
Nursing Nina Cat - Manhattan Toy
Nursing Nina Cat - Manhattan Toy
Nursing Nina Cat
$33.00
Quick view
Nursing Nissa Hedgehog - Manhattan Toy
Nursing Nissa Hedgehog - Manhattan Toy
Nursing Nissa Hedgehog
$33.00
Sold Out
Quick view
Nursing Nola Rabbit - Manhattan Toy
Nursing Nola Rabbit - Manhattan Toy
Nursing Nola Rabbit
$33.00
Quick view
On-The-Go-Making-Faces Manhattan Toy
On-The-Go-Making-Faces Manhattan Toy
On-The-Go Making Faces
$25.50
Quick view
Paws & Claws
$17.50
Quick view
Penny-Penguin-Scrub-a-Dubbie Manhattan Toy
Penny-Penguin-Scrub-a-Dubbie Manhattan Toy
Penny Penguin Scrub-a-Dubbie
$16.00
Quick view
Playdate Friends Alex
$29.00
Quick view
Playdate Friends Ellis
$29.00
Quick view
Playdate Friends Freddie - Manhattan Toy
Playdate Friends Freddie
$29.00
Quick view
Playdate Friends Harper - Manhattan Toy
Playdate Friends Harper
$29.00
Quick view
Playdate Friends Nico
$29.00
Quick view
Playdate Friends Ollie - Manhattan Toy
Playdate Friends Ollie
$29.00
Quick view
Playground Adventure
$130.00
Quick view
Polly Penguin Advent Calendar
$55.00
Quick view
Posh-Pet-Day-Spa Manhattan Toy
Posh-Pet-Day-Spa Manhattan Toy
Posh Pet Day Spa
$23.00
Quick view
Pup Match Up Game
$17.50
Sold Out
Quick view
Ribbit Waffle Maker
$34.00
Quick view
Sleep-Tight-Sleigh-Bed Manhattan Toy
Sleep-Tight-Sleigh-Bed Manhattan Toy
Sleep Tight Sleigh Bed
$50.00
Quick view
Sleepy Time Bear - Manhattan Toy
Sleepy Time Bear - Manhattan Toy
Sleepy Time Bear
$22.00
Quick view
Hunny-Bunny-Beige Manhattan Toy
Hunny-Bunny-Beige Manhattan Toy
Snuggle Pods Hunny Bunny Beige
$22.00